Title
Fragment of the stalls of Santa Clara de Astudillo, Detroit Institute of Arts
Generic classification
FurnitureObject
Choir stallsDate
ca. 1353-1357Century
Mid 14th c.Cultural context / style
GothicMaterial
WoodIconography / Theme
HeráldicaProvenance
Santa Clara of Astudillo (Astudillo, Palencia, Spain)Current location
Detroit Institute of Art (Detroit, United States)Inventory Number in Current Collection
47.91Object history
At the beginning of the 20th century the choir stalls were the object of multiple disposals (Martínez Ruiz, 2008; Yzquierdo, 2008-2009), such as that of Santa Clara de Astudillo (Palencia). In 1931 its dismemberment began. The 50 chairs that made up the stalls were divided: four of them ended up in the National Archaeological Museum (Madrid), ten in the Detroit Institute of Arts (Detroit), while the others ended up in the San Diego Mission (California). Apolinar Sánchez-Villalba, an antiquarian based in Madrid, acquired the set of seats, and was responsible for their dispersal (Martínez Ruiz, 1011).
This antiquarian needed an export permit to be able to sell the chairs outside the country. It was then that Manuel Gómez-Moreno and the Academy of Fine Arts of San Fernando negotiated with Sánchez-Villalba (Martínez Ruiz, 2008; Franco Mata, 2013). The condition sine qua non for the antiquarian to sell the chairs to an American buyer was to donate four of them to the National Archaeological Museum (Madrid). Thus, on March 30, 1931 Apolinar Sánchez-Villalba donated four of the chairs to the National Archaeological Museum. The rest were acquired in Italy, although it is not known with certainty who bought them. Aguiló Alonso (2016) argues that they may have been acquired by the antiquarian Morandotti of Rome, since he painted and modified parts of the chairs on behalf of Daniel Donohue. It is unclear whether Donohue was the next buyer or whether it first passed through the hands of Adolph Loewi. This dealer acquired the seating, or at least part of it, in 1947. Ten of the chairs ended up at the Detroit Institute of Arts (Robinson, 1948), while the rest landed at the San Diego Mission.
Description
The monastery of Santa Clara de Astudillo (Palencia) was founded by doña María de Padilla in 1353. It was declared a National Monument by decree of June 3, 1931. The sillería was composed of fifty chairs of polychrome wood (red, green, pink, white and yellow).
Locations
ca. 1353 - ca. 1931
ca. 1931 - Second quarter of the XXth c.
dealer/antiquarian
Apolinar Sánchez-Villalba, Madrid (Spain) *
ca. 1947 - Third quarter of the XXth c.
dealer/antiquarian
Adolph Loewi, Venecia/Los Ángeles (Italy) *
ca. 1978 - present
Bibliography
- AGUILÓ ALONSO, María Paz (2016): "La sillería de Santa Clara de Astudillo en América: nuevas noticias y apreciaciones", nº 34, Boletín del Museo Arqueológico Nacional, Madrid.
- FRANCO MATA, Ángela (1995): "El actual paradero de la sillería de coro del convento de Santa Clara de Astudillo", en Estudios de Arte. Homenaje al profesor Martín González, Universidad de Valladolid, Valladolid.
- FRANCO MATA, Ángela (2010): "La sillería de Santa Clara de Astudillo", Boletín de la Institución Tello Téllez de Meneses.
- MARTÍNEZ RUIZ, María José (2008): La enajenación del patrimonio en Castilla y León (1900-1936), tomo I, Junta de Castilla y León, Salamanca.
- ROBINSON, Francis W. (1948): "Fourteen century painted choirstalls from Astudillo in Spain", nº 1, Bulletin of the Detroit Institute of Art.
- YZQUIERDO PERRÍN, Ramón (2008): "Sillerías de coro gótico-mudéjares: de Santa Clara de Toro a Santa Clara de Palencia", vol. 40-41, Abrente.
Record manager
Isabel Escalera FernándezCitation:
Isabel Escalera Fernández, "Fragment of the stalls of Santa Clara de Astudillo, Detroit Institute of Arts" in Nostra et Mundi. Cultural Heritage from Castile and Leon around the world, Fundación Castilla y León, 2025. https://inventario.nostraetmundi.com/en/work/42
Fragment of the stalls of Santa Clara de Astudillo, Detroit Institute of Arts
Detroit Institute of Arts, Míchigan. Public Domain
Detroit Institute of Arts, Míchigan. Public Domain