Title
Christ Among the Doctors. Fragment of an altarpiece
painter
Borgoña II, Juan de [attributed to] [workshop of] (Active in Toro (Zamora) between 1534 and 1553)
Generic classification
PaintingObject
PaintingDate
ca. 1560-1570Century
Third quarter of the 16th c.Cultural context / style
RenaissanceDimensions
42,91 x 24,41 inMaterial
PanelTechnique
Oil PaintingIconography / Theme
Cristo entre los doctoresProvenance
Possible origin in the province of León (León, Spain)Current location
Château de Villandry (Villandry, France)Object history
According to Fiz Fuertes (2023), this panel was part of an altarpiece that has since been dispersed, possibly originating from the diocese of Astorga or León. In his study *Painting and Painters in Zamora (1525–1580) *, he identified nine paintings from the ensemble, basing his hypothesis on the uniformity of style, subject matter, and dimensions (Fiz, 2023):
- Nativity: located in the collection of the Château de Villandry (France).
- Jesus Among the Scribes: preserved in the collection of the Château de Villandry (France).
- The Arrest: part of the collection at the Château de Villandry (France).
- Ascension: part of the collection at the Château de Villandry (France).
- St. John the Evangelist: part of the collection at the Château de Villandry (France).
- Saint Paul: part of the collection at the Château de Villandry (France).
- The Presentation in the Temple: It was located at the Hôtel Drouot; however, in 2014, the Il Ponte auction house (Milan) announced its sale. It is currently on the market.
- The Annunciation: It was auctioned in 1985 at Sotheby’s inMonte Carlo. Its whereabouts are unknown.
- Adoration of the Magi: It is in the collection of Hans Rudolf Gerstenmaier.
The first four paintings (The Nativity, Jesus Among the Scribes, The Arrest, and The Ascension) are known thanks to photographs held in the CSIC photo library. These photographs indicate that the works came from a private collection in Tours (France) and were auctioned in April 1986 at the Durán auction house (Madrid, Spain). Around that time, they were acquired for the Château de Villandry (France), where they are currently housed (Fiz, 2023). Beginning in 1899, Joaquín Carvallo, together with his wife Ann Caroline Coleman, began assembling a large art collection at Villandry. In 1951, an inventory was conducted that listed“more than 300 works, more than half of which are attributed to various schools”(Sicco, 2011). After Carvallo’s death, the collection continued to grow through successive acquisitions by his relatives and, later, by the institution itself.
Sicco undertook a study of the Carvallo collection in Villandry, in which the panels of this dispersed altarpiece are mentioned. However, the researcher did not hypothesize that they might belong to the same set and classified them under different schools. The panels depicting the Nativity, Jesus Among the Scribes, the Arrest, and the Ascension were attributed to the“École flamande fin XVIe siècle-début XVIIe siècle.” As for Saint John the Evangelist and Saint Paul, she classified them underthe “16th-century German school”(Sicco, 2011). Currently, the institution considers the first four panels to belong tothe “17th-century Spanish school.”
It was Fiz Fuertes (2023) who formally compared the six panels with the works undertaken by Juan de Borgoña II, a painter closely associated with the Toro (Zamora) school. The commissions this painter carried out for the main altarpiece of Santo Tomás Cantuariense in Toro or for the altarpiece of San Salvador de Abezames suggest that the Villandry panels may have been executed in his circle. Since there are no stylistic features that indicate the presence of Lorenzo de Ávila, Fiz (2023) dated these panels to around 1560, a period when Juan de Borgoña II was active in the dioceses of Astorga and León. Therefore, it seems plausible to conclude that the altarpiece originated in what is now the province of León.
We are grateful for the assistance provided by Irune Fiz Fuertes and by the Château de Villandry, specifically Jérémy Licourt,who is responsible for events, cultural outreach, and promotion.
Description
This panel depicts a scene from the Gospel of Saint Luke. It tells the story of a young Jesus, barely twelve years old, standing among the teachers of the Law and asking them questions. Perplexed by the boy’s intelligence, they are filled with wonder. The figures have a stockier build than in other paintings by John of Burgundy, suggesting that the panel originated outside his circle (Fiz, 2023).
Locations
Second half of the XVIth c.
XXth c.
private collection
Private collection, Tours, Tours (France) *
ca. 1986
auction house
Durán Subastas, Madrid (Spain)
post. 1986 - present
Bibliography
- FIZ FUERTES, Irune (2023): Pintura y pintores en Zamora (1525-1580). Un estudio del caso sobre la asimilación del Renacimiento en el noroeste castellano-leonés y su irradiación, Universidad de Valladolid, Valladolid, pp. 160-162.
- FIZ FUERTES, Irune (2003): Lorenzo de Ávila, Juan de Borgoña II y su escuela. La recepción del Renacimiento en Tierras de Zamora y León, Publicaciones del Centro de Estudios Benaventanos Ledo del Pozo, Benavente.
- SICCO, Laurence (2011): La collection Carvallo au château de Villandry, Le livre d'art, París, pp. 12-13.
Record manager
Isabel Escalera FernándezCitation:
Isabel Escalera Fernández, "Christ Among the Doctors. Fragment of an altarpiece" in Nostra et Mundi. Cultural Heritage from Castile and Leon around the world, Fundación Castilla y León, 2025. https://inventario.nostraetmundi.com/en/work/601