Title
St. Catherine and Mary Magdalen
painter
Maestro de Osma [attributed to] (Active in the late 15th and early 16th centuries)
Generic classification
PaintingObject
PaintingDate
ca. 1500-1516Century
First quarter of the 16th c.Cultural context / style
Hispano-Flemish GothicDimensions
57 1/8 x 47 inMaterial
PanelTechnique
Oil PaintingProvenance
Possible origin from Castile and Leon (Castilla y León, Possible origin from Castile and Leon, Spain)Current location
National Museum of San Carlos (Ciudad de México, Mexico)Object history
In 1947, the American researcher Chandler R. Post attributed this panel to the Master of Osma, a painter active in the late 15th and early 16th centuries. This artist carried out major commissions for the town of Osma (Soria), Corrales de Duero, Curiel de Duero, Langayo (Valladolid), and the present-day province of Palencia. Therefore, although the origin of the piece is unknown, it seems plausible to assume that it was located somewhere in Soria, Valladolid, or Palencia. While the Master of Osma produced numerous works for private devotion (Silva Maroto, 2007), such as the Christ with the Crown of Thorns at the Los Angeles County Museum or the Virgin of the Milk with the Child at Johns Hopkins University, the size of this panel suggests the possibility that it came from an altarpiece.
Alberto José Pani, Mexico’s Secretary of Finance during the first third of the 20th century, was an avid art collector. His position as a cabinet member allowed him to assemble a large collection of European art between 1919 and 1931. He turned his passion for collecting into a project of national significance for the country by donating the works he acquired to state art galleries, an action that placed him at the helm of the construction of the Palacio de Bellas Artes in 1932 (Garduño, 2013). In 1922, he purchased eight paintings to mark the centennial of national independence, and in 1934, he donated eighteen more pieces he had personally selected to the government. Pani recounts that in 1933 he had spent“a week in Madrid to purchase, on behalf of the government and at significantly reduced prices, eight important panel paintings from the Catalan, Valencian, Aragonese, and Castilian schools of the fifteenth century, among which were a Berruguete, the canvases *Saint Francis* by El Greco, *The Penitent Magdalene* by Zurbarán—signed—and *Saint Simon* by Velázquez […]” (Pani, 1940). Unfortunately, it is not specified through which intermediaries he acquired the pieces, but we know that the antique dealer Juan Lafora Calatayud sold him the *Adoration of the Magi* and that Raimundo Ruiz provided him with a panel depicting King David.
After returning to his homeland, Pani deposited the panel with the Mexican Ministry of Finance and Public Credit (Lacouture, Gual, and Toussaint, 1973). This is how the painting became part of the collection of the San Carlos National Museum in Mexico, where it remains to this day.
Description
Saint Calina and Mary Magdalene are depicted. The former holds a spinning wheel and a sword—objects alluding to her martyrdom—while the latter holds her attribute, a jar of perfume. The faces of both women are characteristic of the Master of Osma and are reminiscent of the Virgin and Child, the Assumption of the Virgin, or Saint Agatha. Likewise, the detailed rendering of the clothing and the landscape also point to this artist.
Locations
First quarter of the XVIth c. - XXth c.
ca. 1933 - ca. 1934
private collection
Alberto José Pani, Ciudad de México (Mexico) *
ca. 1934
private collection
Ministry of Finance and Public Credit, Mexico, Mexico (Mexico) *
Second half of the XXth c. - present
Bibliography
- "SS. Catherine and Mary Magdalen", Digital Collections Frick.
- (1963): Maestros Europeos en las Galerías de San Carlos de México, Fondo Editorial de la Plástica Mexicana, Ciudad de México, p. 14.
- GARDUÑO, Ana (2013): "Patrimonialismo y poder: Alberto J. Pani, coleccionista institucional (1919-1934)", en Las artes y la arquitectura del poder, editado por Víctor Mínguez, Universidad Jaume I, Castellón, pp. 1085-1097.
- GAYA NUÑO, Juan Antonio (1958): La pintura española fuera de España (historia y catálogo), Espasa-Calpe, Madrid.
- LACOUTURE, Felipe; GUAL, Enrique y TOUSSAINT, Antonio (1973): "Museo san Carlos de México", nº 164, Artes de México, p. 32 / 54.
- LEAL, Fernando (ed.) (1958): Museo de San Carlos, México City, Ciudad de México, p. 18.
- PANI, Alberto J. (1940): "La segunda colección Pani de pinturas: catalogo descriptivo y comentado", Editorial cultura, Ciudad de México.
- POST, Chandler Rathfon (1947): A History of Spanish Painting, vol. 9 (The Beginning of the Renaissance in Castile and Leon), nº 2, Harvard University Press, Cambridge (Massachusetts), p. 691.
- SILVA MAROTO, Pilar (2007): "Obras para la devoción privada en Castilla a fines del siglo XV: El Maestro de Osma", en In sapientia libertas: escritos en homenaje al profesor Alfonso E. Pérez Sánchez, Museo Nacional del Prado, Madrid, p. 143.
Record manager
Isabel Escalera FernándezCitation:
Isabel Escalera Fernández, "St. Catherine and Mary Magdalen" in Nostra et Mundi. Cultural Heritage from Castile and Leon around the world, Fundación Castilla y León, 2025. https://inventario.nostraetmundi.com/en/work/608